Luxury vinyl vs. hardwood flooring: which is best for you?

Flooring can make or break a room. It’s the foundation of your design and a significant investment, so getting it right matters. You're not alone if you’re torn between luxury vinyl and hardwood flooring. Both have strong benefits, but they’re not identical. Let’s break it down so you can choose the flooring that’s perfect for your space.

What is luxury vinyl flooring?

Luxury vinyl flooring (LVF) is a durable, synthetic material that mimics natural surfaces like wood or stone. It comes in two main types: luxury vinyl plank (LVP) and luxury vinyl tile (LVT). LVP is designed to look like wood, while LVT mimics stone or ceramic tiles.

Luxury vinyl has grown in popularity because it’s waterproof, affordable, and versatile. Unlike older vinyl floors, luxury vinyl features a multi-layer design, including a wear layer that protects against scratches and a photographic layer for realistic patterns.

What is hardwood flooring?

Hardwood flooring is exactly what it sounds like—planks of natural wood. There are two main types: solid hardwood and engineered hardwood. Solid hardwood is a single piece of wood, while engineered wood flooring has a plywood core topped with a thin layer of real wood.

Wood floors have a timeless look and can be refinished multiple times, giving them incredible longevity. They’re often seen as a premium choice, adding value to homes and creating a warm, natural aesthetic.

 

Durability: which stands up better?

Durability is key when choosing flooring, especially if you have kids, pets, or high-traffic areas. Luxury vinyl is nearly indestructible. It’s resistant to scratches, dents, and water. You can spill a drink or track mud inside without worrying about damage.

Hardwood flooring, however, is more delicate. While it’s durable in its own way, it’s prone to scratches, dents, and moisture issues. Spills left too long can warp the planks, and pet claws may leave marks. That said, wood flooring can be sanded and refinished to erase imperfections, giving it a long life if you’re willing to maintain it.

Cost: where’s the value?

When it comes to price, luxury vinyl usually wins. It costs significantly less upfront, and installation tends to be more affordable since many styles are DIY-friendly.

Hardwood is more expensive, both for materials and installation. It’s also worth considering long-term costs. Hardwood might require refinishing every 10-15 years, while luxury vinyl has minimal upkeep expenses. However, hardwood’s premium appeal can increase your home’s resale value, making it a worthwhile investment.

Appearance: natural beauty or stylish mimicry?

Wood floors are stunning. There’s no denying the charm of real wood, with its unique grain patterns and organic warmth. Whether you choose oak, maple, or exotic species like Brazilian cherry, hardwood offers a level of authenticity that’s hard to match.

Luxury vinyl does an excellent job of replicating the look of hardwood and other materials. In some cases, you might not notice the difference at first glance. Advanced printing technology ensures realistic textures and colors, but close inspection will reveal that it’s not real wood.

Water resistance: the ultimate test

Here’s where luxury vinyl shines. It’s completely waterproof. You can install it in bathrooms, kitchens, or basements without worry. Spills, splashes, and humidity won’t cause damage.

Hardwood flooring is not water-resistant. Even engineered wood flooring, which handles moisture better than solid wood, can’t match the waterproof capabilities of luxury vinyl. If water exposure is a concern in your home, luxury vinyl is the safer choice.

Maintenance: keeping it clean

When it comes to cleaning and maintenance, luxury vinyl is a breeze. A quick sweep or mop keeps it looking fresh, and it doesn’t require special cleaners. It’s resistant to stains and scuffs, so it stays low-maintenance over time.

Wood flooring, while not overly difficult to maintain, does require more care. You’ll need to clean it with wood-safe products and protect it from excessive moisture. Rugs and furniture pads are essential to prevent scratches. Over time, you may need to refinish wood floors to restore their luster.

Comfort: how does it feel underfoot?

Wood floors feel sturdy and natural. They’re warmer than tile but cooler than carpet. Adding area rugs can make hardwood cozier, but the solid surface is hard underfoot.

Luxury vinyl has a slight give, making it more comfortable to walk on. Some versions even include an attached underlayment for added cushioning. If you stand for long periods, luxury vinyl may be the more comfortable choice.

 

Installation: DIY or professional?

Luxury vinyl is a favorite for DIYers. Many styles feature a click-and-lock system, allowing you to 

install them without professional help. It’s lightweight and can often be placed over existing flooring.

Hardwood installation is more complicated. Solid hardwood needs to be nailed or glued down, and engineered hardwood flooring sometimes requires a floating installation. Either way, professional installation is usually recommended, which adds to the cost.

Longevity: how long do they last?

Hardwood flooring wins in longevity. When properly cared for, wood floors can last 50 years or more. They can be refinished several times, extending their lifespan even in high-traffic areas.

Luxury vinyl is durable, but it doesn’t last as long as hardwood. Most luxury vinyl products are rated to last 10-20 years, depending on the brand and level of wear. While that’s impressive for the price, it’s not a match for hardwood’s lifespan.

Eco-friendliness: which is greener?

Many homeowners are becoming increasingly concerned about sustainability. Wood floors, when sourced responsibly, are a renewable resource. Look for certifications like FSC (Forest Stewardship Council) to ensure the wood comes from sustainable forests.

Luxury vinyl, being synthetic, isn’t as eco-friendly. Some brands are making strides toward greener manufacturing processes, but most luxury vinyl isn’t biodegradable. However, it does last a long time, reducing the need for replacement.

Which flooring is right for you?

So, what’s the verdict? It depends on your lifestyle, budget, and priorities.

• Choose luxury vinyl if you want a budget-friendly, waterproof, and low-maintenance option that’s ideal for busy households.

• Opt for hardwood if you value natural beauty, longevity, and a premium feel.

In the end, there’s no right or wrong choice—just the one that fits your needs. Take your time, consider your options, and imagine how each flooring type will feel in your home.

Contact us for luxury vinyl and hardwood flooring in Kennewick, WA

Murley's Floor Covering proudly offers a diverse selection of high-quality luxury vinyl and hardwood flooring in Kennewick, WA. We've been serving the Tri-Cities area with beautiful floors and top-notch services since 2005. Reach out to us when you're ready to get your dream floors!